In The Culting of America (2026), organizational psychologist and cult survivor Daniella Mestyanek Young defines a cult by ten traits, paraphrased here. Each is followed by how it appears in tainoism.
A charismatic leader
The group follows a leader whose authority rests on personal appeal, not on an accountable office.
Charismatic “chiefs” and “caciques,” with titles of the groups’ own making and an ambiguous hierarchy. In tainoism, the taino concept is also presented as a charismatic leader by way of “the ancestors.”
A sacred assumption
The group is built around a core belief that members may not question.
That a continuous taino people survived and that members descend from it: a fantasy of secret ancestry, hidden in the mountains for five hundred years, supported by a 94-person DNA study repeated in tainocentric circles and academia as “60% of all Puerto Ricans” (see question 6).
A transcendent mission
The group pursues a cause presented as larger than any one life.
“We exist,” “survivance,” “we’re still here”: slogans that pave the way for the idea that taino groups’ “recognition efforts” can be realized, federal recognition as a Native American tribe through the Office of Federal Acknowledgment and international recognition through the United Nations (see the Timeline, 1998), even though the paper trail of the taino concept does not precede the 20th century (see the Timeline, 1903–04 and 1916).
Self-sacrifice
Members are expected to put the group ahead of their own needs.
In tainoism, taino always comes before one’s own moral compass, to advance the taino concept at any expense.
Limited access to the outside world
Contact with outside people, information and identities is restricted.
Tainoism discourages contact with people, information and identities outside the taino belief system. Followers are isolated from real Boricua and Caribbean heritage; primary records are demonized and discredited, ranked below tainocentric secondary and tertiary sources. Family members who challenge the taino concept are called “colonized,” and spouses who do not go along with becoming taino are deemed “unsupportive.” Once the tainoist is free of an unsupportive spouse or parent, marrying into a federally recognized tribe is encouraged as a way to “decolonize.”
An insider language
The group develops its own vocabulary that marks who belongs.
The taino language, unique to each taino group that has published a taino language book. A recruit who shows interest in the language advances in tainoism by learning it: the more of the language a person learns, the more clout they hold in tainocentric circles as being more “taino.” Other insider terms include “tribe,” “enrollment” and “caciques” (see the Timeline, 1998).
Us versus them
The world is divided into insiders and outsiders, and the line is enforced.
The world is divided into the “colonized” (non-tainos) and tainos who are “reconnecting” with their taino culture. The line is viciously enforced through social shaming of dissenters and by isolating tainoists from any outside resources that challenge the taino concept.
Exploited labor
Members’ work is taken without fair return.
Tainoists are expected to protect the taino concept online and off, to insert it into schools and workplaces, and to attend, work and promote powwows and tainocentric events, all without compensation.
High exit costs
Leaving costs a member relationships, identity or standing.
Disaffiliating from tainoism costs the person the community they once trusted and the relationships built within it, personal identity, and standing, including organizational backing as an Indigenous Native American taino.
The ends justify the means
Any method is acceptable if it serves the goal.
Historical accounts rewritten to insert taino where the original never used it, as with Enriquillo (see The Archive).